How to Set Your S Corp Reasonable Salary (Without Guesswork)

Setting a reasonable salary for your S Corp is essential for maximizing tax savings while staying within IRS guidelines. Paying yourself too much or too little can lead to costly outcomes, from unnecessary payroll taxes to potential IRS penalties. Automating this process with Lettuce helps you avoid these risks and keep more of your money where it belongs.

Setting your own S Corp salary can feel like guesswork. How much is “reasonable”? What’s too high or too low? Between conflicting advice, IRS rules, and endless spreadsheets, finding the right number can be overwhelming. The smarter way? A salary grounded in real data, clear compliance standards, and a system that does the math for you.

Your S Corp salary isn’t just a checkbox. It’s your biggest lever for tax savings. Set it too low, and the IRS might reclassify your distributions as wages, hitting you with 15.3% in payroll taxes plus penalties. Set it too high, and you're voluntarily paying thousands more in employment taxes than necessary. The sweet spot is a defensible number that boosts take-home pay while keeping you audit-ready.

Lettuce turns that sweet spot into certainty, real-time data, IRS rules, and a salary that evolves with you. Simple, confident, and designed to save you more.

Is Lettuce right for you?

See if Lettuce can help you keep more of what you earn with our short quiz.

Take Quiz

What Is a Reasonable Salary?

A reasonable salary is the amount the IRS requires S Corp owners to pay themselves as wages for the work they do before taking distributions. Unlike distributions, this salary is subject to payroll taxes such as Social Security and Medicare. Getting it right matters because it impacts both compliance and your tax savings.

The IRS defines “reasonable” using two main factors:

• Industry standards: what someone with your role, skills, and experience would earn on the open market
• Company performance: the income and profitability of your S Corp

Think of it as the paycheck you’d give yourself if you were hiring someone else to do your job. Because business results and market rates change, a reasonable salary isn’t a one-time calculation—it’s an ongoing benchmark. When set correctly, it keeps you compliant and maximizes how much you keep through distributions.

Stop Leaving Money on the Table: Why S Corp Salary Matters

Your reasonable salary is more than paperwork. It draws the line between wages (subject to payroll taxes, such as Social Security and Medicare) and distributions (not subject to these taxes). That line matters because it directly impacts how much money stays in your pocket.

Here is why finding the right number matters:

• Avoid overpaying in taxes: A salary that is too high means you are paying thousands more in payroll taxes than necessary.
• Stay IRS-compliant: A salary that is too low can be reclassified as wages, leaving you with back taxes, penalties, and interest.
• Protect your tax advantages: Structuring your salary correctly ensures you are not missing out on legitimate savings tied to S Corp distributions.
• Defend your decision: Documenting your salary against industry data and business performance creates proof that your number is fair and defensible.

When your salary reflects your role, effort, and company performance, you hit the sweet spot: IRS compliance and meaningful tax savings working together. That balance is what makes the S Corp structure so powerful for solopreneurs.

That is where smart automation helps. Solopreneurs no longer need manual calculations or clunky spreadsheets. Lettuce's automated payroll systems use your business income, industry standards, and IRS rules to generate salary recommendations that keep you compliant while maximizing take-home pay.

IRS Rules, Decoded: What Counts as a Reasonable Salary?

The IRS doesn’t expect you to play a guessing game with your salary. They want it to reflect fair market value. It’s the kind of pay someone with your role and responsibilities would earn if you were hiring them on the open market.

In practice, that comes down to a few commonsense factors:

• Industry standards: Research what similar businesses pay for your specific duties and experience level, not generic "consultant" rates.
• Business profits: Higher-earning S Corps typically justify higher salaries, but the IRS looks at profit margins and industry benchmarks together.
• Time on the job: The more hours you put into daily operations, the bigger your paycheck should be compared to someone focused only on strategy.
• Qualifications and experience: Training, skills, and years in the field all shape what’s considered fair pay.
• Local market rates: Pay in San Francisco looks very different from pay in small-town Kansas.
• Documentation: Keep notes on how you arrived at your number. If questions come up, you’ll be ready.
• Prepare for IRS scrutiny: The agency can reclassify your distributions as wages if it determines that your salary falls short.
• Expect additional employment taxes: Reclassification triggers employment taxes of 15.3% on the underpaid amount.

And yes, the IRS has the power to step in if they think your salary is out of line. Take the case of David E. Watson, P.C. v. United States (2012). David Watson was a CPA who elected S Corp status and ran his own professional corporation. He worked full-time, often 35 to 45 hours a week, but set his annual salary at just $24,000. At the same time, he pulled in hefty distributions of about $203,000 one year and $175,000 the next.

The IRS wasn’t buying it. They argued that $24,000 was far below what someone with Watson’s skills and workload would reasonably earn in the market. An IRS expert testified that a fair salary for him would have been just over $91,000 a year. The court sided with the IRS, reclassifying much of his distributions as wages and making them subject to payroll taxes.

The lesson? If your business depends on your own services, your salary has to match the real value of that work.

How Lettuce Calculates Your S Corp Reasonable Salary

With Lettuce, you never have to crunch the numbers yourself. Lettuce's AI-powered system automates your salary using real-time data, industry benchmarks, and IRS rules. No spreadsheets, no second-guessing, just a salary that’s defensible, IRS-compliant, and optimized for maximum tax savings.

Here’s how the automation works step by step:

1. Automate Salary Calculation From Your Net Income

The moment Lettuce sees your business’s net income, it automatically allocates a portion to payroll based on IRS guidelines and industry standards. For example, if your S Corp nets $200,000, Lettuce may start with the 60/40 framework, at least 60% ($120,000) as salary and the rest ($80,000) as distributions. That salary is subject to Social Security and Medicare (the 15.3% FICA rate), but it’s also deductible for your business, keeping you compliant while lowering your taxable income.

2. Separate Salary and Distributions With Compliance Built In

Distributions aren’t subject to payroll taxes, but they do show up on your personal return. Lettuce keeps the salary/distribution balance automatically documented so you meet IRS expectations without second-guessing.

3. Benchmark Against Your Industry and Workload

Automation doesn’t mean one-size-fits-all. Lettuce cross-checks your role against Bureau of Labor Statistics data, industry surveys, and IRS precedents. A solopreneur consultant working 20 hours a week won’t see the same salary recommendation as a CPA putting in 45 hours.

4. Factor in Your Personal Tax Picture

Other income streams, like a spouse’s W-2, investment gains, or freelance side gigs, can shift the ideal mix of salary and distributions. Lettuce builds this into the equation while also protecting your cash flow. Lettuce also recommends keeping 30–40% of income in your account to ensure salary and tax obligations are covered. As the system learns your income patterns, it automatically adjusts in real time.

5. Automate Payroll and Filings

Once your salary is set, Lettuce handles the mechanics. It runs payroll, withholds FICA automatically, and files quarterly Form 941 with the IRS. At year-end, it generates your W-2. Everything is filed, paid, and documented without manual work on your end.

6. Monitor Continuously and Adjust in Real Time

Businesses don’t stand still, and neither should your salary. Lettuce monitors your income throughout the year and sends alerts if adjustments are needed. That way, the salary you set in January won’t leave you exposed in October.

You also get worry-free tax compliance. Lettuce handles payroll taxes, Form 941, your W-2, and salary-to-distribution tracking to keep you compliant and save thousands without the need for an accountant or HR software. It’s how Lettuce helps you avoid IRS reclassification, and the penalties and interest that come with it.

FAQs: S Corp Salary Decisions Made Simple

When it comes to paying yourself through an S Corp, the rules can feel confusing. These questions come up often for solopreneurs, so here are clear answers you can rely on.

How does the IRS define reasonable compensation for S Corp owners?

The IRS expects your salary to reflect fair market value, which is what you would pay someone else to do your job. They consider your role, skills, experience, time commitment, and regional pay standards. This salary is subject to payroll taxes, including the 15.3% FICA rate for Social Security and Medicare, before you can take distributions.

What happens if my S Corp salary is too low or too high?

If your salary is too low, the IRS can reclassify your distributions as wages and charge back taxes, penalties, and interest. If it is too high, you are overpaying in payroll taxes instead of keeping more through tax-advantaged distributions. The goal is a defensible salary that balances compliance and savings.

Can I adjust my S Corp salary during the year?

Yes. Your salary is not fixed for the whole year. It should adjust as your business grows, profits change, or your workload shifts. The key is to document why you made the change so it is defensible if reviewed.

How does Lettuce handle salary changes for me?

Lettuce tracks your business income in real time. If your numbers shift, the system recalculates your salary, alerts you, and updates your documentation. That way, you stay compliant without having to redo the math yourself.

What records should I keep to justify my salary?

The IRS expects proof. This includes salary surveys, your duties, hours worked, and comparisons to similar roles. Lettuce automatically keeps this documentation for you, including the data and reasoning behind your salary. It becomes your built-in audit defense file.

Take Control: Automate Your Salary and Tax Savings with Lettuce

Setting your S Corp's reasonable salary doesn’t have to be a quarterly headache. Lettuce automates the process so your salary is audit-ready from day one, freeing you to focus on growth instead of wrestling with spreadsheets.

Your business deserves the same financial tools big companies use, sized perfectly for one. With real-time tax projections, compliance monitoring, and CPA-backed support, Lettuce keeps payroll and taxes optimized automatically.

Stop overpaying. Automate your S Corp salary with Lettuce and keep more of what you earn.